Gaiam Life - Wellness, Green Living, Spirituality, Fitness, Yoga & Healthy Home
 
  Subscribe | Discussion Boards | Videos | Newsletter
Login     Register
Forum Name: Health & Wellness
Outline View
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
Gaiam Staff
posted Jan 2, 2007 1:12:51 PMTo All
In light of the recent studies that estrogen might be linked to breast cancer, what has been your best or worst experience with a doctor or the healthcare system?
Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
Aerangis
posted Jun 7, 2007 2:59:07 PMTo All
Which studies are you referring to?
Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
sandra
posted Jun 8, 2007 9:27:44 AMTo All



On Jun 7, 2007 2:59:07 PM Aerangis wrote:

Which studies are you referring to?
There are many different opinions on how much estrogen is responsible for breast cancer, but I think it's generally agreed that estrogen hormone therapy should be used very carefully (only to relieve menopause symptoms and NOT for prevention).

Here are a few links I found online

Estrogen & Breast Cancer Risk: The Relationship: http://envirocancer.cornell.edu/FactSheet/General/fs9.estrogen.cfm

Causes of breast cancer — the estrogen controversy: http://www.womentowomen.com/breasthealth/estrogenbreastcancer.asp

No link between estrogen therapy, breast cancer: http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2006/april12/med-breast-041206.html

Hormone Therapy: http://www.cancer.org/docroot/CRI/content/CRI_2_4_4X_Hormone_Therapy_5.asp
Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
Aerangis
posted Jun 8, 2007 10:02:40 AMTo All

Thanks for the links.  I will take a look and comment.  I think for lay people there is a misconception about what/when hormone therapies are safe!  We discussed this with our OB recently and she suggested that the studies that suggested increased risk of cancer were related to hormone replacement therapy, i.e., menopausal women, versus contraceptive use of estrogen.  None the less, we all should be careful about what we put into our bodies, or expect our spouses to take for our benefit, and know the associated risks/benefits. 


I wonder if you, or anyone reading, has information about the differences between risks/benefits of phytoestrogens/synthetic estrogens.  I have found some, but, wonder what your take is on this area.

Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
Aerangis
posted Jun 8, 2007 10:41:13 AMTo All

Excellent links!  Not the actual studies, but, good food for thought.  I particularly like the women to women article and  the article from the Stanford researcher. 


I think that it is interesting that the focus of most of the information regarding hormone use is focused on death and cancer risk.  I think that it is important to look at overall satisfaction from a quality of life perspective when using any medication.  That includes physical benefits and side effects, mental/emotional/behavioral side effects or benefits, and risk of fatal illness from all causes, i.e., heart disease, stroke (blood clots), and cancers.  In my opinion, this is a very complex issue that is very likely different for each person.   I suppose that is why I like the women to women article that suggested more a more holistic approach and life long look at hormone use/exposure.


There are several new large studies out of the UK regarding HRT and risk of ovarian cancer and a look at the recent drop in cancer rates in the US attributed to mammogram saturation and HRT use reduction. 


Search under "hormone replacement therapy cancer risk" and separately "estrogen cancer risk"


http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?db=pubmed

Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
Thoughts on the Healthcare System 
GranolaJoe
posted Jun 11, 2007 11:48:24 AMTo All
*EDIT: I think Neilkirk was spamming

Edited by: GranolaJoe on Jun 18, 2007 12:40:11 PM

"We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect." -Aldo Leopold
Ignore User  |  |  Report Post
[1]

How to survive family gatherings

“I feel out of sync with my family of origin around the holidays, when I spend more time with them than usual,” wrote one reader recently. “They aren’t interested in honest communication, working on relationships, or other things that are important to me … How can I deal with this in a positive way? This question [...]

10 cold-weather gear essentials for outdoor workouts

Believe it or not, research shows that you burn more calories working out outside in the winter than you do in the summer because you use more energy keeping your body warm. Use this must-list to arm yourself with essential cold-weather workout gear to keep you safe, warm and motivated in winter weather.

6 cool & affordable green gifts for eco-travelers

Looking for a holiday gift for that eco-conscious globetrotter — or a traveler you’d like to help “green up”?  Check out these creative yet practical gifts that won’t add too much excess weight to your credit card. And when you shop online, you lighten the burden on the earth by avoiding extra car trips. 1. Carbon [...]

What Happens to Recyclables After They Are Collected? and More

Play ConcentratiOm, the new yoga memory game by Gaiam, for the chance to win fabulous prizes. Also featured: the process of how recyclables go from being collected to becoming newly manufactured products, conflicting opinions of yoga instructors and the effect of music during practice, and more in this week's Living Roundup.

Winter composting: Should I just scrap it?

Nice … half-frozen veggie scraps molded together in a solid mass. Not exactly what I want to see in my compost bin. With at least five more months of cold weather before warmth and sunshine reappear, why do I even bother keeping the pile going? Me and my veggie scraps Well, I guess I do know why. [...]

Answering Your Questions About “Organic”

What is organic? What does organic mean? These are two different versions of the most-asked question about organic. In a broad sense, organic simply means that it is made from animal or vegetable compounds. In the stricter sense that many of us have come to expect, organic means that only animal or vegetable materials were used in the making of the product from start to finish.

The 5 stages of green (and how to get to the best one)

How do I remain upbeat, knowing what I do about our planet’s peril? The secret to getting through the stages to a place of optimism and hope.

“Glass half full” is step 1 in getting healthier

In all my experiences as a fitness trainer for all types of people, I have never met anyone who thought they were doing everything they could to take care of themselves. I’ve been in the fitness industry for two decades. We are so much smarter now about how our bodies work — yet we are facing [...]

Grab Our Widgets for Daily Green Deals and Yoga Pose Tips

We’ve launched two cool new widgets that we think you’ll absolutely love! Introducing the Gaiam Green Deal of the Day and Rodney Yee’s Daily Yoga Pose. It’s easy to add them to your blog, iGoogle page, Facebook, Myspace and other popular social networking sites — simply press “Share” on the lower right hand corner of [...]

What Environmentalists Can Expect From Obama & More

What environmentalists can expect from Barack Obama when he becomes president, how parents can teach children about giving from an early age, and more in this week's Living Roundup.


Shop Gaiam.com       My Profile       Contact Us       Privacy Policy       Terms & Conditions       About Gaiam Life       FAQ's       Register       Site Map

Copyright © 2008 Gaiam, Inc.